Skip to content
RestaurantsApps

Direct ordering vs. DoorDash and Uber Eats: working out the commission math

Updated 7 min readBy the Brevity Technologies team

On this page

On a $30 delivery order, a US marketplace commission of 15% to 30% costs a restaurant $4.50 to $9.00. A direct order costs about $1.17 in card fees plus any delivery cost you don't pass on, so direct ordering wins on repeat customers and marketplaces win on discovery. We've built direct ordering for restaurants in New York, and most should keep both.

Key takeaways

  • A 15% to 30% commission costs $4.50 to $9.00 on a $30 order.
  • A direct order costs about $1.17 in card fees, plus any delivery cost you don't pass on.
  • Direct ordering wins most clearly on pickup, where there's no delivery cost at all.
  • Marketplaces still bring new customers, so most restaurants should keep both.

Published commission tiers

Both big US apps sell tiers, where a higher commission buys more delivery reach and marketing. These are the published US rates as we checked them in November 2026, and promotions, local law and your contract can change them.

ServiceDelivery commissionPickupYour own drivers
DoorDash15%, 25% or 30%, by planCheck current planCheck current plan
Uber Eats20%, 25% or 30%, by plan7% with validated in-store pricing, otherwise 10%15%

A $30 order, three ways

This example assumes a $30 food subtotal. It leaves out food cost, packaging, tips and tax, and it assumes the restaurant covers the delivery cost in the direct column, which most restaurants pass on to the customer at least in part.

ItemMarketplace at 15%Marketplace at 30%Direct, with white-label delivery
Commission$4.50$9.00$0
Card processingIncludedIncluded$1.17
DeliveryIncludedIncluded$7.99 or less if the customer pays part
Cost if the restaurant absorbs it all$4.50$9.00$9.16
Cost if the customer pays delivery$4.50$9.00$1.17

Card processing here uses Stripe's standard US online rate of 2.9% plus 30 cents. Delivery uses the "as low as" price from Uber Direct, so your actual cost depends on distance and market. The result is plain: direct delivery only beats a 30% plan clearly when the customer pays some of the delivery fee. Pickup is where direct ordering wins outright, because there's no delivery cost at all.

To run this with your own orders and fees, use our free restaurant commission calculator.

New York City has its own caps

If you're in NYC, the old 23% figure is out of date. Local Law 79 of 2025 caps delivery at 15%, a basic service fee at 5% and transaction fees at 3%, and it allows an enhanced service fee of up to 20% only alongside the basic service. Added up, that's a maximum of 43%, though monthly averaging applies. The city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection publishes the current requirements, and the city has enforced the rules against at least one app.

What the math leaves out

A marketplace brings customers who've never heard of you, and that's worth paying for. Your own site or app only works on people who already know you, so somebody has to send them there. Direct ordering also brings costs that don't fit in the table:

  • Building or licensing the ordering system, and keeping it running
  • Handling complaints and refunds that a marketplace would otherwise absorb
  • Marketing to get repeat customers to order directly
  • Keeping menus and prices in sync across each channel

What you get back is the customer relationship: an order history, a phone number you can message with consent, and a reason for someone to come back without paying a commission each time.

Getting delivery without the marketplace

You don't need your own drivers. Uber Direct and DoorDash Drive both offer white-label delivery, where the customer orders from you and the network only carries the food. You pay per delivery, with no commission, so the economics are predictable. That's how a platform like Quick Bite Now offers delivery under each restaurant's own domain.

A sensible way to run both

  1. Stay on marketplaces for discovery, on the lowest plan that still gets you found.
  2. Add direct ordering for pickup and repeat customers first.
  3. Offer a reason to order direct, such as a first-order discount or loyalty points. Check your marketplace contract before you set different prices.
  4. Put your direct ordering link on your packaging, receipts and Google Business Profile.
  5. Send all orders to one place in the kitchen. Tablets for each channel cause mistakes at peak times.
  6. Each quarter, compare what each channel keeps per order and how often customers return.

We built this setup for Whitestone Bagel Factory and Teriyaki Bowl, each with a website, Android and iOS apps, web ordering, and DoorDash and Uber integrations. Our mobile app service has more on how we'd approach yours.

Frequently asked questions

What commission do DoorDash and Uber Eats charge restaurants?

As published when we checked in November 2026, DoorDash's US delivery plans were 15%, 25% or 30%, and Uber Eats' were 20%, 25% or 30%. Uber Eats listed pickup at 7% with validated in-store pricing, otherwise 10%. Promotions, local law and your contract can change these.

Is direct ordering cheaper than DoorDash?

Usually for pickup, and for delivery when the customer pays some of the delivery fee. If the restaurant absorbs all of a white-label delivery fee, a direct order can cost about as much as a 30% plan. You also pay for the ordering system and the marketing that brings people to it.

What are the delivery app fee caps in New York City?

Local Law 79 of 2025 caps delivery fees at 15%, a basic service fee at 5% and transaction fees at 3%, and allows an enhanced service fee of up to 20% only alongside the basic service. That adds up to a maximum of 43%, with monthly averaging allowed.

Sources

  1. DoorDash: merchant pricing
  2. Uber Eats: merchant pricing
  3. Uber Direct
  4. DoorDash Drive
  5. Stripe: US pricing
  6. NYC Local Law 79 of 2025
  7. NYC DCWP: delivery app requirements

Checked on November 2, 2026. Rates and rules change, so confirm them at the source before relying on them.

Keep reading.

All insights
AutomationOdoo

How to automate support email with AI on Odoo and Microsoft 365

Read post
WhatsAppHospitality

WhatsApp chatbots for hotels: upsell flows guests don't mind

Read post

Tell us what's slowing your team down.

One call is usually enough to tell whether software is the answer, and what to build first if it is.